Tuesday, December 26, 2006

Europe hating America?

Todays’ question is directly derived from this blog. One of the comments on “tell me a story” hoped that the Europeans didn’t hate the Americans that much, because one of them (me) remembered a German soldier bringing food to his mother when he was a baby, thus maybe forgetting the food droppings carried out by the Americans during the famine winter in Holland in 1944-1945. My question in response to this comment is: how come that some American lady would react like that? Not all Germans were beasts and we in Holland remember every year at 5 May the liberation thanks to the lion’s courage of American soldiers. But isn’t that special, a German soldier risking his life by bringing food to a hungry mother with her child? I think that the Americans, at least an important, mainstream group among them, suffers a bit from blindness for other views on the world than the U.S. as the most important country with grateful helped countries around them. Of course, the USA did many good things in the world. But if you compare the brave things they did in World War 2 with war efforts after that, one sees ungrateful “liberated” countries and failures, despite so many American lives. Europeans are grateful for their liberation from Hitler c.s., but that’s not the case with Vietnamese, Somalians, Iraqi people, people in Afghanistan, Pakistan, Palestine, Venezuela, etc. How come? Let’s try to analyse a bit. I think the American “mainstream” culture consists of two more or less contradictory tendencies: one is a strong emphasis on democracy and freedom of press and speech (originated from the same roots as the French Revolution which owed much to Freemasonry), the other one is a very straightforward and orthodox Christian evangelism (which owes much to immigrant believers, the “founding fathers”and their clergymen). Sometimes these tendencies clash, e.g. in the discussion about homosexuality, about whether or not evolution theory must be brought forward in education, about whether or not America has a mission in the world, etc. The protestant roots of mainstream culture are also manifest in the phenomenon that in human sciences such as sociology, economics, business sciences etc. there is always a “scientific branch” which follows the rules of modern science, and an “evangelist branch”. There is so much American literature that “preaches” how to improve this-and-that, how to grow, how to be the best, etc. We Europeans then look for research-arguments and for discussion, but this is often lacking. If you ask me for examples, I can give them but it would need too much space here. I only mention one, and that’s the Covey-hype. Covey is a management and individual-growth guru whose activities resemble very much the activities of Billy Graham . Take also for instance Americans following training courses: U-formed tables, and within the U the trainer walks his rounds, in shirt (to stress his dynamic personality), and every now and then bowing over a trainee, his fists on the table. Europeans find this intimidating. Also talkshows and TV programs reflect this need for “doing things better” or making confessions about a “sinful” and failed past life. (Ophra, Doctor whatshisname again, etc.).
In short, mainstream American culture doesn’t seem to bother much about other cultures, because theirs is superior they think. The USA refuses to take part in worldwide environmental care agreements (Tokyo), they don’t acknowledge international courts, and even threaten publicly (Bush’s administration) to invade Holland when an American will be held prison for the The Hague War Criminal’s Court of Justic": Americans just can't commit war crimes. They accuse also Europe that the USA has to do the dirty work when it comes to military action, without asking why Europe is not so greedy for foreign wars (just see how they work out), and ignoring UN-resolutions.
All this jeopardizes America’s role as “Europe’s big brother”, let alone America’s role in the rest of the world. The USA regret the postponements of Turkey’s EC membership, but what if Mexico would apply for membership of the USA?
In Holland we have a former soccerplayer, Johan Cruyff, who enriched our language with a new proverb: “Every advantage has its disadvantage”. So American culture seems to be superior, just because during decades they were the “promised Land” for so many immigrants, and still they fulfil a benefiting role in many areas in the worldwide arena. They are the most democratic country next to Great Britain, just because they had to come to terms with the mentioned two contrasting tendencies. Go to an anti-American activist in an Islamic country and offer him a job and a house in the U.S. Provided that he can bring some family with him, he will most certainly forget his anti-American feelings immediately. All humans, whether Euopean, American, etc. want to belong to a culture which they prefer for themselves as most desirable. Conflicts arise when people want to impose their culture on others. And that’s what mainstream American culture doesn’t want to see. It is extremely difficult to return on this path because of the thousands of Americans who fell in the wars for a better “more American-looking” world. But, as said by Cruyff, the world also owes much the USA: a democratic example, economic wealth because of their buying power, their hospitality as an immigrant country in the past which saved e.g. so many hungry Irish, their will to spend great amounts in scientific research, their movie-culture, literature, arts, music, etc. They were also victims of the t-word (which I don’t want to mention in a text readable for the whole world), on which they over-reacted by starting a dangerous war, feeding the criticisms every day more and more.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

Careful falling into cliches about America. My experience is Europeans live (willfully because you have many alternative sources of information) in a bubble controlled by socialist journalists and a socialist educational establishment and popular media in general.

This may seem off-topic, but this short blog post touches on this subject:

http://hughhewitt.townhall.com/g/102d7fe5-0622-4ad7-bb77-92d86ad19d8d

America is a Christian nation, and it is defending freedom on this planet, and the devil and his followers (unconscious followers as well as conscious followers) don't like that. So there is alot of justification for this hatred of America and Satanic excuse-making for the most corrupt evil elsewhere, but it comes down to spiritual matters. The majority of the world has the 'spirit of disobedience' coursing throught it. That spirit is of the Kingdom of Satan.

There is the Kingdom of God and the Kingdom of Satan, if you're not in one you're in the other. No in-between. No opting out.

Erik said...

Just as I thought. Oh, and I forgot to mention the Americans as our shield of protection during the Cold War. But to discuss about what Caroline brought forward seems quite senseless. She only supports my opinion about the USA and not only minde I believe and I hope one day we can come together. Thinking that your own country, culture and belief is superior to all others is desastrous. Where did we see or experience that before? America owes just as much to the Freemasons who you probably will think are the Army of the Satan, as to the Protestant Founding Fathers. For the rest I am Roman Catholic and feel myself just as less a servant of Satan as you do.

Evie said...

Erik, I think you've articulated quite well the issues that non-Americans have with the USA. I'm American and I love my country, but I'm not blind to the fact that our foreign policy is often arrogant and frequently misguided. The fact is, the USA has made - and is making - some grievous mistakes in both foreign and domestic affairs. We are paying the prices for those mistakes and will continue to do so until we undertake more sensible courses of action.

I respect Caroline's right to hold her religious beliefs, but I don't agree that all matters can be analyzed through the lenses of spirituality. Moreover, I don't believe that the USA is the Voice of God or Agent of God on earth today. The sooner we reject that self-righteous, arrogant attitude, the sooner we can get down to the urgent business of working with other nations to resolve the serious problems that affect us all.

Robert said...

One thing that saddens me more than anything about this beautiful planet and its occupants is the terrible things we as humans have done and will not doubt continue to do in the name of God.

Christ taught us to love one another; The story of the Good Samaritan says it all.

No to be totally naive, someone has to police this world, but wisely, learning from past mistakes (Vietnam & Suez). Recent events since 9/11 have not worked well. Have we lost the moral high ground? How do we now regain it? Not through arrogance. Through humility and accepting we could do better.

Erik said...

Robert, I totally agree.

The problem is I think, that we are not ruled by intellectuals and philosophers but by democratically chosen leaders who want to give a voice to what they see as the feelings of their voters. Instead of leading them to humility and modesty, they rather follow them. This process is reinforced by the media. Most people also tend to think of themselves as morally good humans, but others will assess them otherwise, and this doesn’t result in self-criticism but in self-defense against the critics.
The Dutch author Multatuli (E.D. Dekker) criticized colonialism in Indonesia (in his novel Max Havelaar) by pointing at orthodox-Christian, wealthy people, attending church 2 times each Sunday, while owning coffee-plantations and exploiting poor Indonesians. They found themselves morally very good! And these Indonesians weren’t they “only” in-convertible Muslims?
I agree we need one or more prophets: a prophet appeals on self-criticism by striking us with good arguments we can recognize. Al Gore perhaps? Or the pope, if he will be prepared to play a mediating role between West and East, maybe in co-operation with Israelian leaders? There is a couple of candidates, but there is also (that’s the problem) always a group of nations not recognizing him/her as a prophet.